Luxury Vinyl vs. Linoleum Flooring: An In-Depth Comparison

Linoleum and vinyl are two unique materials for floor treatments. Both these floorings are similar in some aspects. However, there are multiple astonishing aspects that differentiate these two materials. Basically, Linoleum is a natural flooring material composed of composite materials such as wood flour, cork dust, pine resin, linseed oil, and some other substances. Whereas Vinyl is a synthetic flooring material made of Polyvinyl Chloride, plasticizers, and resins. In this detailed comparison, we have compared both of these flooring materials in all aspects. 

Vinyl Vs Linoleum Flooring | A Comprehensive Comparison

e basis of multiple aspects such as durability, appearance, lifespan, cost, comfort provision, noise reduction, water and heat resistance, and multiple environmental considerations. Moreover, Flooring Abu Dhabi have also compared both these flooring materials by considering their cleaning, maintenance, and installation procedures. 

Appearance

Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl flooring offers you a wide variety of patterns, colors, and images because this flooring material has a layer with multiple printed design options beneath the wear layer. These intricate designs and patterns can give an attractive look to your home floors.

Elegant stone-look vinyl tiles
Elegant stone-look vinyl tiles

Linoleum Flooring 

In Linoleum flooring, the color and patterns are submerged in the entire flooring thickness rather than just printed on one layer like vinyl flooring. This flooring restricts the variety of options for crafting new aesthetics on your floor.

Evaluating Criteria: Appearance 
Final Verdict: Vinyl Flooring is the Best Choice 
Linoleum Flooring
Linoleum Flooring

Water and Heat Resistance

Vinyl Flooring

Modern Vinyl flooring offers greater water resistance for your floor due to its fiberglass backing. This feature makes it a great choice for installing in damp or moist places. Whereas, the backing layer in older vinyl flooring is not resistant to water. If we talk about heat resistance, this flooring type has low heat resistance, easily burns, and releases harmful fumes. 

Classic white vinyl tiles
Classic white vinyl tiles

Linoleum Flooring

Linoleum flooring is somewhat water-resistant. This type of flooring doesn’t offer entire water resistance, as in case of high flooding linoleum flooring can be damaged. Moreover, for heat resistance, Linoleum flooring is an excellent choice. Because this flooring doesn’t easily burn and release harmful fumes. 

Evaluating Criteria:  Water & Heat Resistance
Final Verdict: Vinyl Flooring is the Best Choice 
Water Flooring
Water Linoleum Flooring

Care and Cleaning

Vinyl Flooring

This flooring can be easily cleaned with the help of a vacuum cleaner. You can also use an appropriate detergent or floor cleaner to mop it. In addition, this flooring is also resistant to mold and mildew, so you can easily clean the surface smoothly. 

Linoleum Flooring

Likewise vinyl, Linoleum also offers easy cleaning with a vacuum or home detergents. This flooring type is most favorable for high foot traffic areas or commercial places such as hospitals, schools, and hotels. However, this flooring is prone to mold or mildew growth.

Evaluating Criteria:  Care & Cleaning
Final Verdict: Tie

Durability and Maintenance

Vinyl Flooring

As vinyl flooring is crafted with both the design layer and a strong wear layer (PVC layer), this makes it a durable and scratch-free flooring material. In addition, to prevent the material from water and stains, no waxing or sealing is required incase of vinyl flooring. 

Durability and Maintenance Vinyl Flooring
Durability and Maintenance Vinyl Flooring

Linoleum Flooring

Likewise vinyl flooring, this type of flooring is also durable but prone to wear and scratches due to its softer profile than vinyl. Furthermore, this flooring material requires periodic sealing or waxing to prevent it from water and staining. 

Evaluating Criteria: Appearance 
Final Verdict: Tie
Luxurious marble flooring detail
Luxurious marble flooring detail

Installation

Vinyl Flooring

The installation of vinyl flooring is smooth and easy but the precise cutting of large vinyl sheets is somewhat difficult for DIY projects. However, vinyl tiles can be easily installed and are the best choice for DIY enthusiasts. Nowadays, vinyl tiles with already applied adhesives are available in the market. 

Installation Vinyl Flooring
Installation Vinyl Flooring

Linoleum Flooring

Likewise, the installation of Linoleum flooring is easy and smooth but placing linoleum sheets is somewhat more difficult than vinyl sheets. However, for DIY projects, linoleum tiles or planks are also available.

Evaluating Criteria:  Installation
Vinyl Flooring is the Best Choice 
Linoleum Flooring Installation
Linoleum Flooring Installation

Cost

Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl flooring requires a lower cost than Linoleum flooring. However, the final cost of this flooring also depends upon the supplier, design style, and material quality.

Linoleum Flooring

Unlike vinyl flooring, this flooring is more expensive. The final cost of linoleum flooring also depends on the manufacturer, chosen style, and whether it is linoleum sheets or tiles. Because linoleum sheets are more expensive for flooring than tiles or planks.

Evaluating Criteria: Appearance 
Final Verdict: Vinyl Flooring is the Best Choice

Lifespan

Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl flooring can last up to 20-30 years with minimal maintenance and care. Moreover, due to its scratch-resistant structure, this flooring can maintain its shiny appearance for longer periods of time.

 

Lifespan Vinyl Flooring
Lifespan Vinyl Flooring

Linoleum Flooring

Linoleum flooring can last up to 40 years with the right maintenance and care. Moreover, linoleum flooring lifespan also depends upon its periodic waxing or sealing. 

Black & White Flooring
Black & White Flooring
Evaluating Criteria:  Lifespan
Final Verdict: Linoleum Flooring is the Best Choice 

Resale Value

Vinyl Flooring

Due to its long-term shiny appearance, high durability, and superior water resistance, buyers give more value to vinyl flooring. So we can say that vinyl flooring is the best option to enhance residential resale value. 

Linoleum Flooring

Due to its scratches, low durability, and water suspension, linoleum flooring cannot add value to your home. Unlike vinyl flooring, linoleum is not a good choice if you want to enhance your place’s resale value. 

Evaluating Criteria:  Resale Value
Final Verdict: Vinyl Flooring is the Best Choice

Comfort and Sound

Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl flooring is crafted with hard material, making it comfort-free for feet. However, this flooring is less noisy than others.

Linoleum Flooring

Linoleum flooring has a soft material, which makes it a good choice for comfort provision. 

Evaluating Criteria:  Comfort & Sound
Final Verdict: Linoleum Flooring is the Best Choice 

Environmental Considerations

Vinyl Flooring

Vinyl flooring is usually composed of some toxic chemicals and carcinogenic elements. When vinyl flooring burns, it secretes these harmful chemicals that may affect human health. Moreover, these harmful chemicals persist in the porous areas of flooring.

Linoleum Flooring

As linoleum flooring is manufactured with natural materials such as wood flour, cork dust, linseed oil, and pine rosin, it is a healthy and chemical-free option.

Evaluating Criteria: Environmental Considerations
Final Verdict: Linoleum Flooring is the Best Choice 

Final Remarks!

In conclusion, Vinyl flooring has a strong potential to stand up better. If we consider the durability, appearance, resale value, cost, installation, water, and heat resistance, we can say that vinyl flooring is an excellent choice. In addition, if we consider the comfort, lifespan, and environmental considerations, we must choose the Linoleum flooring. Overall, Vinyl flooring has been a better choice due to its remarkable features.

Related Articles

How Can Parquet Flooring Increase the Value of Your Property
Luxury Vinyl Flooring Treatment
Fantastic Outdoor Flooring Ideas That Will Transform Your Patio
Why Parquet Flooring Is The Perfect Choice For Your Home
Pros And Cons Of Vinyl Flooring For Your Kitchen
Wood Parquet Flooring Review